Prefer to listen…. ?
https://youtu.be/uN3aZR2bQaI?is=8LDtdK4QXSPXzoBu
Imagine your favorite football team is looking to hire a new coach (this may hit too close to a few of us this fall!). As your team is searching, you begin building an attribute list for candidates to narrow down who would be a good fit for your program. Here's the list.
The Coach
The coach needs to be able to recruit highly skilled players and develop the players to hone their skill in order to execute on game day.
The coach needs to be able to lead his team. Set the vision for the culture of the program and create systems to maximize the potential of his team.
The coach needs to be highly verbal, able to rally his team, encourage them, and motivate them to victory with his voice.
This all makes sense enough… but the description keeps going. We also need the coach to be able to play on the field (I understand we are losing some of reality here… but bear with me). This list would look something like this.
The Quarterback
The coach must play on the field… preferably quarterback.
He needs to play the position better than anyone else, while understanding the position of everyone else on the field.
Between plays he needs to have the technical skill and energy to set up, manage, and troubleshoot all the technical components of game day (headsets, tablets, communication, etc).
This is really starting to build up… but we aren't done yet! Stay with me…. The job also needs to get done on a part-time clock. Keep reading…
The Clock
The coach will split this role with also coaching the baseball team.
He's allotted 20 hours a week for each role.
Now… does this seem ridiculous? Absolutely it does. We would never ask a coach to do this. It would lead to utter failure of the program and burnout of the coach. No one would win. Yet, in my experience, this is not far off from the job description we continue to hand worship leaders without blinking. Most worship leaders' job descriptions look something like this.
The Coach
Must be able to recruit, train, and coach worship team members.
Must be able to shepherd the congregation through planning services and admonishing the congregation.
The Quarterback
Must be able to sing and play an instrument to lead a band and congregation.
Must lead the AV team (recruit, train, coach…etc).
The Clock
Part time: 20 hours a week.
Notice anything interesting? This job description and the one we laid out for our hypothetical coaching position aren't all that different. Let me explain.
The Coach
This one sounds normal. It's the part of the job most of us signed up for… and honestly, it's good. We should expect worship leaders to lead people. But let's slow down and look at what we're actually asking.
They shepherd the congregation, building services that disciple people instead of just filling time. They get a 90-second window between songs and are expected to say something edifying in it. They pastor during the week: hospital visits, hard moments, phone calls in the evening. And they equip the team (Ephesians 4:12) and build its culture, from team nights to the hard conversation with the guy who's late every single week. But you can only coach what you know. How do you train a drummer when you don't play drums?
Here's the catch. Every item on this list is relational… and relationships take unhurried time. Hold that thought.
The Quarterback
This one seems obvious. We need worship leaders to… well… lead worship. They have to sing and they have to play an instrument. Non-negotiable. But I think we undersell what that actually takes.
Count the reps: two services, a run-through, rehearsal, maybe a worship night. That's easily 25 to 30 songs a week. I know a handful of worship leaders who've had surgery for nodes. And it's not enough to just play. You have to play well enough to pull a drifting band back together, then explain to the bass player how his part should sit with yours. Add tracks, in-ears, and sound, because if the mix is bad on Sunday, who does everyone come looking for? (It's you.)
Every one of these skills only stays sharp with practice. So when does practice happen? When I was on staff, I felt guilty practicing during work hours. Nobody did that to me… that was all me.
The Clock
Here's where it all comes to a head. Most worship leaders I know are part-time. Either they're bivocational, or they're full-time staff where worship is half (or less) of the job. Sound like a certain coach who also runs the baseball team?
Quick math on a typical week: Sunday morning (6 hours), rehearsal (2), another service (2), staff meeting (2). That's 12 hours… gone. And you haven't planned, practiced, recruited, or sat down with a single person. None of that coach list made the cut.
Worship Leader Research's 2025 survey backs this up. The top three stressors for worship leaders were balancing ministry and personal life (63.8%), high workload with limited resources (46.2%), and pressure to meet congregational expectations (43.9%).
I lived this. One Sunday I led two services, a Connect team meeting in between, and our first-time guest class after. I remember thinking, this is too much, and I'm not even doing it well. I called it all love for God's people, and it was. But I had to come to an honest conclusion about my own limits.
So… Now What?
We would never hire that football coach. But we do it every week in the church.
So… do I think the worship leader role is awful and we should blow it up? No. Many of us would say we were called to this. I would too. But I do think we need to rethink how we accomplish the job, and that starts with being honest about where we are. Here's what I'd ask you to do this week.
Evaluate your time. Take 10 minutes and write down where last week's hours actually went: the Coach, the Quarterback, and the Clock. A number is easier to talk about than a feeling.
Name the stressor. "I'm tired" is hard to act on. "Most of my week goes to the Quarterback, and the Coach gets almost nothing" is something you can bring into a conversation. So which hat is wearing you out the most? Tell me using the form below. I'd love to hear from you.
Tune in next week. On the next episode of Music and Mission, we'll talk through some strategies to not just survive this job, but thrive in it.
